Panel Discussion: Evaluating the UFC Commentary Dream Team

After Laura Sanko’s spectacular pay-per-view debut at UFC 293, the MMA world is buzzing with talk about the best UFC commentary team. We gathered our own group of experts, Shaheen Al-Shatti, Steven Marrocco, Jed Meshew, and Damon Martin, to weigh in on their ideal commentary lineups in a post-293 world. Let’s dive into their insights and opinions.

Al-Shatti’s Perspective: A Shift in the Winds

Al-Shatti, our seasoned MMA observer, starts by acknowledging the prevailing phenomenon in the MMA community—Joe Rogan’s formidable presence. Any critique of the “Podfather” is met with fierce opposition from his loyal followers. However, something extraordinary unfolded at UFC 293. Al-Shatti admitted that if the UFC introduced more of Laura Sanko’s talent and less of Rogan’s on major shows, he’d be thrilled. To his surprise, the MMA world seemed to agree, a rare moment of unity in this diverse sport.

Sanko’s exceptional preparation and on-mic sharpness breathed new life into the commentary booth. Al-Shatti believes that with time, this trio—Jon Anik, Laura Sanko, and Daniel Cormier—could establish a new standard for UFC commentary. Anik’s class in play-by-play, combined with Cormier’s infectious enthusiasm and Sanko’s expertise, make for a promising team.

Martin’s Stance: Stick to the Classics

Martin, on the other hand, advocates for the old adage: “If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.” He firmly believes that the trio of Jon Anik, Joe Rogan, and Daniel Cormier remains the go-to team, especially for pay-per-views. These marquee events demand the most memorable commentary, and Rogan’s iconic voice has become synonymous with legendary UFC moments.

Martin acknowledges Laura Sanko’s exceptional performance but emphasizes the value Rogan brings to the table. Cormier’s enthusiasm and intelligence also make him a valuable asset in the booth. While he concedes that Cormier could dial it down occasionally, he has unwavering faith in Cormier’s commentary abilities.

In Martin’s eyes, the status quo is still the reigning champion, and no one is ready to dethrone this commentary trio.

Marrocco’s Take: Embrace the Professionalism

Marrocco congratulates Laura Sanko on her impressive pay-per-view debut and proposes a lineup featuring Sanko, Jon Anik, and Paul Felder. He values professionalism and accessibility, describing this trio as the most suitable choice on the current roster. It’s a lineup that strikes a balance, avoiding the excessive bro-culture, caustic commentary, or overbearing presence found elsewhere.

Marrocco also recognizes that age catches up with everyone, including Joe Rogan. He suggests that it might be time for producers to consider fresh voices, given the demands of the job. Additionally, he advocates for Anthony Smith and Dan Hardy to have opportunities in the commentary booth.

Meshew’s Unique Perspective: Embrace Change

Meshew brings a unique perspective, emphasizing the inevitability of change in the world of MMA commentary. He argues that commentators are like perishable goods, with a shelf life of about three years due to the relentless nature of the sport. Over time, the grind can transform even the most respected voices into caricatures of themselves.

Meshew doesn’t want to see Laura Sanko succumb to this fate. Instead, he playfully suggests bringing back Mike Goldberg, the man who “cannot be corrupted.” While Goldberg’s commentary may be objectively flawed, it often provides entertainment and talking points for fans. Meshew sees a place for nostalgia and humor in the commentary booth, even if it means embracing some imperfections.

In Conclusion:

The UFC commentary landscape is ever-evolving, with each expert offering a unique perspective on the ideal team. Whether it’s preserving the classics, embracing professionalism, or injecting some humor and nostalgia, the discussion around the best commentary team is as diverse as the sport itself. Only time will tell if Laura Sanko’s impressive debut marks a turning point in UFC commentary or if the classics will continue to reign supreme.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about UFC Commentary

More about UFC Commentary

• Laura Sanko’s UFC 293 Debut
• Joe Rogan’s Role in UFC Commentary
• Jon Anik’s Play-by-Play Expertise
• Daniel Cormier’s Commentary Style
• Paul Felder’s Broadcasting Skills
• Anthony Smith’s Potential in Commentary
• Dan Hardy’s Commentary Contributions
• Mike Goldberg’s Memorable Commentary